Lori Vallow’s niece and Matthew Farwell’s twin brother were each close enough to see what was happening. Psychotherapist Shavaun Scott and retired FBI behavior chief Robin Dreeke join me for the full panel on Melani Read more…
Christopher Quaratino was seven years old when his stepfather moved him into a house where four children had been shot in their beds thirteen months earlier. Thirty years later, he called George Lutz “a perpetrator Read more…
Matthew Farwell’s twin, William, was a cop and was seeing Sandra Birchmore himself when she told him she was 15 the first time Matthew slept with her. He did nothing. Psychotherapist Shavaun Scott joins me Read more…
Three people entered Gypsy Rose Blanchard’s life at different points, and none of them came out whole. Dee Dee Blanchard fabricated her daughter’s illness for twenty-three years and was killed in the house charities built Read more…
Melani Boudreaux had a Gilbert detective swear she was a person of interest in the shooting at her husband, and her aunt Lori Vallow had just been arrested over JJ and Tylee. A week later, Read more…
With the jury out on October 28th, the Matthew Farwell trial had two fights over what jurors will hear and decide. Farwell’s lawyers want a former boyfriend of Sandra Birchmore to testify about choking in Read more…
Melani Boudreaux testified that Lori Vallow and Chad Daybell taught her some people carried “some type of darkness that you couldn’t cast out,” and that the whole idea was “constantly changing.” By November 2019 she Read more…
Lori Vallow’s niece, Melani Boudreaux, lost her mother as a child, and the call telling her came from Lori. By the fall of 2018, Lori was inviting Melani to religious firesides, and Brandon Boudreaux testified Read more…
“I did.” That was William Farwell’s answer when a prosecutor at the Sandra Birchmore trial asked if he’d ever been intimate with Sandra while on duty as a Stoughton officer. He testified under immunity, so Read more…
On the evening of November 13, 1974, Ronald “Butch” DeFeo Jr. ran into his regular bar on Merrick Road in Amityville and told the men at the counter that his parents had been shot. By Read more…
Had the Anna Kepner case stayed in juvenile court, her stepbrother Timothy Hudson would have been released by 21 with no criminal record. Instead, he’s in federal court as an adult, charged with first-degree murder. Read more…
In March 2026, Gypsy Rose Blanchard appeared in a TikTok joking about murder. In August, leaked prison recordings surfaced — calls from 2020 and 2021 where she told a friend she hoped Ken Urker would Read more…
Bryan Kohberger initialed nine pages of plea paperwork when he pleaded guilty to the University of Idaho murders in July 2025. One question on the plea form asked whether he’d been coerced, and he checked Read more…
Matthew Farwell’s twin brother William promised Sandra Birchmore in October 2020 that he wouldn’t say a word about her and Matthew, and on October 27th he told a federal jury what else he kept to Read more…
The Norfolk District Attorney’s office declined to charge anyone in the Sandra Birchmore case after medical examiner Dr. María del Mar Capó-Martínez ruled the death a suicide. At Matthew Farwell’s federal trial, she testified the Read more…
Former Stoughton, Massachusetts police officer William Farwell testified under immunity at the Farwell trial, where his twin brother Matthew is accused of killing Sandra Birchmore and her unborn child. Matthew pleaded not guilty. William’s immunity Read more…
Robin Dreeke and I cover three stories built on claims about what people knew. Ken Urker was found dead on his 34th birthday with a holstered gun, two shot glasses and a syringe on his Read more…
The DeFeos bought 112 Ocean Avenue in Amityville, New York, in June 1965, with Louise’s father’s money. They put a sign in the yard that said High Hopes. Nine years later, on November 13, 1974, Read more…
Matthew Farwell’s defense spent October 23rd arguing Sandra Birchmore took her own life, using her own words against her. Robin Dreeke and I go through what they used and what they left out. Farwell’s lawyer Read more…
Nicholas Godejohn met Gypsy Rose Blanchard on a Christian dating site around 2012. She used an alter ego. He had his own. Over the next three years, their messages moved from romance to logistics — Read more…
Gypsy Rose’s account of Ken Urker’s death has moved, and the evidence hasn’t. Soon after he was found dead on October 1st, she told People he likely overdosed and she didn’t know if it was Read more…
Matthew Farwell’s defense leans on Sandra Birchmore’s 2021 suicide ruling, and on October 26, 2026, the doctor who made it answered both sides at his federal trial in Boston. Defense attorney Kimberly Stevens took her Read more…
Melani Pawlowski says she knew nothing about the plan to kill Brandon Boudreaux. Robin Dreeke and I test that against her own words and the people around her. The day after the shot, she told Read more…
Melani Pawlowski has never been charged in the October 2019 shooting at Brandon Boudreaux, even though Lori Vallow Daybell’s prosecutor told a jury she was in on it. Robin Dreeke and I lay out what Read more…
DA Tim Cruz has not said whether Lindsay Clancy faces a second trial. Eleven of twelve jurors sided with the defense, and the one who didn’t had a restraining order against him during the trial. Read more…
On the first Homicide Happy Hour, former thirty-year pastor Timmy Gibson traced the line between Caleb Flynn and JP Miller. Flynn was convicted on all nine counts in Ashley Flynn’s murder and sentenced to life Read more…
Timothy Hudson’s defense team told a federal judge that one unresolved issue is preventing them from deciding whether their client pleads guilty or goes to trial for the murder of his stepsister Anna Kepner. They Read more…
Marc Flasterstein wrote “Munchausen by proxy” in Gypsy Rose Blanchard’s chart after a muscle biopsy at Tulane came back negative. The biopsy confirmed Gypsy’s muscles were healthy. The chart said Dee Dee Blanchard was fabricating Read more…
Sandra Birchmore entered a police explorer program as a twelve- or thirteen-year-old girl. The officers who allegedly targeted her had unchecked access to vulnerable minors through that program. No meaningful background checks. No oversight. Multiple Read more…
Two women who knew Sandra Birchmore best took the stand in the Matthew Farwell murder trial on October 23rd, and both described a woman getting ready to be a mother. Lindsey Crean, her friend since Read more…