Three details from the crime scene testimony reportedly tell investigators more than any single piece of forensic evidence could. A towel placed over Ashley Flynn’s head. A front door that was unlocked despite alleged signs Read more…
Alleigha Botner testified that on February 14 Caleb Flynn messaged her that he was finally free of Ashley Flynn and had told Ashley he wanted a divorce. FBI forensic examiner Sarah Stuchell, meanwhile, conceded on Read more…
The Nolan Wells no true bill came with a detail buried in the district attorney’s video statement: the family’s own lawyers had already told her they had no evidence a crime was committed. Tony Brueski Read more…
FBI forensic examiner Sarah Stuchell testified that the toolmark testing in the Caleb Flynn case produced a complicated result: some marks were consistent with a hammer seized from the Flynn home, while her written report Read more…
Jill Smith’s phone rang at 3 a.m. on February 16. It was her son-in-law, Caleb Flynn, telling her someone had broken in and shot Ashley. On the third day of the Caleb Flynn trial in Read more…
Det. Zachary Farkus and FBI Special Agent Sarah Deamron put the alleged break-in door under a microscope in the Caleb Flynn trial. Farkus testified that he saw no pry marks, no damage suggesting the door Read more…
Two law-enforcement witnesses put the alleged break-in door itself at the center of Caleb Flynn’s trial. Det. Brad Kline testified that debris from the broken garage access lock was inside the garage and that, based Read more…
Prosecutors did not have to speculate about motive. They had a digital archive. Over 100,000 text messages between Caleb Flynn and his mistress, sent over the course of months while he was still married to Read more…
The prosecution’s case against Caleb Flynn arguably begins and ends with a phone call. At approximately 2:30 a.m., Caleb dialed 911 and reported that his wife Ashley had been shot. He told the dispatcher he Read more…
Jesse Lee Calhoun grew up in Troutdale, Oregon, dropped out of high school, and racked up two decades of criminal convictions — assault, drugs, weapons, burglary. The Multnomah County Sheriff’s Office called him a prolific Read more…
Latent print expert Vicki Bartholomew testified that palm and latent prints recovered from the Flynn property matched Caleb Flynn. But on cross-examination, she acknowledged a key limitation: she could not determine when any of those Read more…
Patrick Clancy told 60 Minutes he was at Boston Children’s Hospital when Callan was airlifted after January 24, 2023. He believed his youngest son might survive. He described making one plea — a three-word bargain Read more…
BCI ballistics experts Aaron Schultz and Alex Miller testified about the bullets and shell casings recovered in the investigation into the killing of Ashley Flynn, and what the markings on that evidence told them. Schultz Read more…
The father published the method. The son inherited the house. Five women appear dead on the hard drives. And nobody opened the door until a parking violation forced it. Raymond “R.C.” Horsch—National Merit Scholar, IQ Read more…
Four Bureau of Criminal Investigations forensic scientists walked jurors through the DNA work in the Caleb Flynn trial, ending with the conclusion Andrea Weisenburger said she reached after reviewing the testing from Ashley Flynn’s home. Read more…
Rachel Danis asked the most natural question in the world. Patrick Clancy answered with two words that no first date is built to carry. Patrick told 60 Minutes he moved to New York City specifically Read more…
ATF Special Agent and K9 handler David McMullen testified about the search outside the Flynn home after Ashley Flynn was killed. McMullen said he and K9 Hilton thoroughly searched around the house and along the Read more…
Caleb Flynn told a 911 dispatcher that a burglar shot his wife, and the state’s answer in the first two days of trial was a stack of his own text messages. This is the Caleb Read more…
Todd Smith, father of murder victim Ashley Flynn, testified about Caleb Flynn’s finances, his future inside the family business, and the moment he began wondering whether his son-in-law could have been responsible for Ashley’s death. Read more…
Kayla Keyt, sister of murder victim Ashley Flynn, testified about Caleb Flynn’s place inside the family business—and the financial future she said had been discussed with him before Ashley’s death. Keyt testified that Caleb earned Read more…
Caleb Flynn is on trial on charges including aggravated murder in the death of his wife, Ashley Flynn. Officer Will Roberts testified that Caleb voluntarily provided DNA, fingerprints, and clothing around noon on February 16, Read more…
Patrick Clancy’s 60 Minutes interview delivered one detail about Lindsay Clancy’s psychiatric care that reframes the entire case. Lindsay checked herself into McLean Hospital in early January 2023, told the doctors she wanted to go Read more…
Day 2 of the Caleb Flynn murder trial moved deeper into the digital side of the investigation. Tipp City Police Officer Luke Velvman testified that he drafted search warrants for records tied to Caleb Flynn, Read more…
On February 16, 2026, Caleb Flynn called 911 and told a dispatcher that someone broke into his Tipp City, Ohio, home and shot his wife Ashley twice in the head. He said an intruder came Read more…
Day 2 of the Caleb Flynn murder trial moved from the original crime scene into the evidence work that followed. Tipp City Police Detective Adam Bernard testified about collection efforts in the days after Ashley Read more…
One was a worship leader in small-town Ohio who told American Idol cameras he loved his wife more than anything. The other was a Myrtle Beach megachurch pastor whose congregation shielded him while his estranged Read more…
Day 2 of the Caleb Flynn trial moved deeper into the physical evidence with Ohio BCI crime scene technician Holly Ryszek and forensic pathologist Dr. Bryan Casto. Ryszek focused on what investigators tested inside the Read more…
Elizabeth Siders pleaded not guilty to 23 charges on September 16, including four felony counts alleging the abuse of a child who is not one of her 16. She appeared in court visibly pregnant. Her Read more…
David Hammond’s cross-examination in the Caleb Flynn trial put one missing piece squarely in front of the jury: investigators never recovered the firearm used on Ashley Flynn. Hammond, a special agent with the Ohio Bureau Read more…
John-Paul Miller’s federal trial is set for October 2026, but the investigation didn’t take the summer off. Miller was indicted in December 2025 on federal charges of cyberstalking and making false statements to investigators. The Read more…